Legal obligations for compensation for Belgian leases via location description
A digital location description provides decisive evidence in 93% of court cases. This guide makes the legal framework, exceptions and evidence crystal clear.
What you'll learn in this article
- The legal framework for compensation and liability
- Concrete criteria for normal wear versus accountable damage
- Force majeure situations and their legal consequences
- The evidential value of digital versus paper documents
The legal framework
Article 1730—1735 of the Dutch Civil Code and regional legislation
The basic principles of the Civil Code
- Article 1730 of the Dutch Civil Code: Tenant must return the item as received, unless damaged due to age or force majeure
- Article 1731 of the Dutch Civil Code: Without a description of the place, the tenant is deemed to have received the property in good condition
- Articles 1732—1735 of the Dutch Civil Code: Arranging liability for fire, water damage and other cases
Regional disparities since 2019
- Flanders: Damage after 9 years = normal wear and tear, unless negligence
- Wallonia: Depreciation tables per element (e.g. parquet = 25 years)
- Brussels: Guidelines + mandatory pre-trial mediation
Normal wear and tear
Concrete criteria and case law
Legal definition and interpretation
- Time factor: After 5 years, slight scratches or discolorations are not recoverable
- Use: More residents = more wear and tear (e.g. children)
- Material selection: More expensive materials = higher expectations
Examples of normal wear
- Floors: Walkway wear, minor scratches
- Walls/ceilings: Yellowing, hairline cracks, nail holes
- Sanitary: Limescale, discoloured silicone, light scratches
Examples of unacceptable damage
- Negligence: Mold, burn marks, blockages
- Intentional: Holes, graffiti, broken windows
- Maintenance defects: Broken appliances, rust, moisture damage
Force majeure
When no one is liable
Legal definition
- Unforeseeable
- Inevitable
- Beyond the control of parties
Examples of force majeure
- Natural disasters: Floods, hail > 2 cm, storm > 100 km/h
- Fire: Due to lightning or external cause
- Crime: Burglary, vandalism (if reported in time)
The burden of proof lies with the tenant
- Needed: Police report, expertise, time stamp, witnesses
- Digital help: GPS, automatic timestamps, weather data, notification history
Digital evidence
The new standard
Legal recognition
Equivalent to paper since 2016, provided that:
- Authenticity: eID, itsme or blockchain
- Integrity: Changes traceable via audit trail
- Accessibility: Available for at least 10 years, downloadable
Practical benefits in court cases
- Faster procedures: 65% shorter sessions
- Stronger evidence: 89% success rate with digital evidence
- Lower costs: From an average of €1,850 to €750
Practical implementation
From theory to practice
Set up digital documentation
- Technical setup: Camera ≥12MP, offline app, power bank
- Workflow: First overview, then space by room
- Signing: Directly digitally by the tenant
Claims handling with digital tools
Notification (within 24 hours):
- Open digital location description
- Request photos
- Log communication
Assessment (within 48 hours):
- Analysis: normal wear and tear?
- Check depreciation tables
- Document decision
Communication (within 72 hours):
- Submit substantiation + case law
- Allow comments via the platform
- Log everything
Preventive measures
- Periodic inspections: 2x/year with digital checklist
- Tenant education: Video, reminders, notification system
Frequently asked questions about digital evidence
Do judges accept digital evidence?
Yes, legally recognized and often even preferred since 2016.
What if the tenant does not have a smartphone?
Paper is still allowed. However, you are allowed to archive digitally for yourself.
How long do digital photos remain legally valid?
As long as original metadata files remain available.
Can I use WhatsApp?
Yes, but a professional platform offers better preservation and overview.
What happens in case of a cyber attack or loss of data?
Use tools with daily backups, distributed servers, and good SLAs. Consider cyber insurance.
Conclusion
Digital is the future of evidence
Legislation and technology are aligned. Digital location descriptions increase your legal certainty, accelerate dispute resolution and reduce costs.
With a 93% success rate in court cases with digital evidence is it clear:
digitize = protect.